| Player | Pos. | Year | Points | Team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Christian McCaffrey | RB | 2019 | 468.0 | Baker is A Dumpster Fire |
| Josh Allen | QB | 2023 | 385.0 | BLESSED |
| Christian McCaffrey | RB | 2023 | 382.0 | BLESSED |
| Davante Adams | WR | 2020 | 359.0 | Positive Vibes Only |
| Matt Ryan | QB | 2016 | 352.0 | THE TOM BRADY MID-FINGER TOUR |
| Ryan Tannehill | QB | 2020 | 343.0 | Positive Vibes Only |
| Justin Herbert | QB | 2020 | 336.0 | Positive Vibes Only |
| Antonio Brown | WR | 2018 | 329.0 | Spotty WiFi |
| Odell Beckham Jr. | WR | 2015 | 327.0 | Ben's Trophies |
| Russell Wilson | QB | 2019 | 327.0 | Baker is A Dumpster Fire |